I had a grandfather who, as Joan would say, liked “to trumpet to the herd.” When he trumpeted, everyone hurried to do whatever he demanded, and never ever, not once, challenged him. He was in his mid-60s when I first noticed this, the age I am now, and I can’t imagine getting away with that. It would not only be a violation of my marital relationship, it would contradict my Quaker principles. Plus, Joan would kill me. Have you noticed that the second halves of our lives is spent unlearning the first halves of our lives.

My grandfather’s pattern of dominance was common, and I’m sure you could offer your own examples of this pattern in your lives. It happened here at Fairfield. When I arrived here, it had not been uncommon for older men in the meeting, men like my grandfather, accustomed to getting their way, lock horns in our monthly meeting for business, trumpeting to the herd. I was warned about this, and was told stories of bruising battles, of raised voices, of people storming from the meeting angry, vowing never to return.

While I wasn’t here to witness these conflicts, I happened to be present when they ended. Sarah Lookabill was our clerk. We were in the old meetinghouse, having our monthly meeting, a subject was raised for discussion, tensions escalated, and before long there were two loud camps, having at one another. I sat there thinking, “What in the world have I gotten myself into?”

Then Sarah raised her hand, asked for silence, and said, “We’re not going to do this anymore. It is not good for us. We are free to disagree. We are not free to be disagreeable.” And she gave the warring parties the “look.” You know the “look.” The look your mother used to give you when you were a kid and needed to straighten up. She gave us the “look,” and no one said a thing. We just sat there, behaving ourselves. With those four sentences, Sarah changed the culture of our meeting. We’re not going to do this anymore. It is not good for us. We are free to disagree. We are not free to be disagreeable.

The world heard that same truth clearly spoken at the polls this past week, didn’t we? We’re not going to do this anymore. It is not good for us. We are free to disagree. We are not free to be disagreeable.

In the past two weeks, I’ve been talking about the things I’ve learned from my time at Fairfield, and today I want to tell you that Fairfield has taught me how to disagree well. You have taught me that disagreement is fine, that a healthy community can have a variety of beliefs and personalities. In fact, the more, the merrier. What a community cannot have, if it wants to thrive, is a spirit of contention that makes cooperation and progress impossible.

In this week’s news, we learned the Four Corners area of the United States has received so much rain that torrents of water have destroyed in a few weeks geological features that took hundreds of thousands of years to form. The same is true for hatred, for incivility, for coarse and abrasive behavior. They can destroy in an instant the cultures of cooperation and civility that took generations of goodwill to build. They are the whirling winds and waters that undermine the monuments of civilization. Sadly, there will always be people in every culture who prefer the whirling wind and water, who prefer dramatic destruction over calm construction. It is more exciting, more exhilarating, and it makes for a more interesting story.

I confess that at certain moments in my life, I have found myself strangely drawn to the torrents of water that destroy. I’ve been attracted to the hurricane and not the refreshing breeze. I don’t know why that is. I only know it is a part of me that needs healing. Now here is what you have done for me. In my adult years, you have taught me that far more gets done in the cooling balm of cooperation than in the blistering heat of discord.

I don’t know how many of us were fortunate enough to know David Siemantel, a former member of this meeting who passed away in 2019. David was a mechanical engineer by trade, but his hobby was blacksmithing. Every year, on the day after Christmas Day, when my son Sam was in junior high and high school, we would drive to Dave’s house out in the country and make something at David’s forge.

There’s an interesting phenomenon in forging iron that is also instructive in human affairs, and that is this: It is not the heat that lends strength to the iron. You might think that’s the case when you watch a blacksmith at work, that the real power is the heat. But that isn’t true. It is what follows the heat that creates the strength, when you take the red-hot iron and plunge it into cool water. It is called quenching, and quenching does two things—it maintains the metal’s shape, then it hardens the iron, making it useful and durable.

When iron is heated in a forge, it becomes malleable and can be shaped. We know that’s true. If we create a lot of heat, a lot of fire, we can shape things. My grandpa knew that. He’d get red-hot, he’d become a hot head, and just that quick, he could shape the environment around him. How many times have you seen people try to change the world by yelling at it, by generating heat and not light. We’ve been watching a political movement do that for the past ten years, haven’t we?

But it doesn’t last, because in order to last it has to be cooled. It’s the cooling that makes the iron sustainable and usable. Now here’s where you came in. When I first arrived on your shores, I was prone to heating up. I spoke bluntly, often with little regard for the feelings of others. I had an inflated opinion of myself. I didn’t think I was God, but I did suspect God and I were first cousins. And you were the bucket of water that cooled me down. You did that with kindness, with honesty, with the power of a good example. Anyone can get heated up, and get others heated up with them. But to cool people down, to quench them, to add strength to their lives and character, is a rare gift. It is a gift you gave me, for which I am grateful. You taught me how to disagree agreeably.

Give that same gift to your next pastor. If he or she gets worked up, and they will because most pastors do from time to time, you be the cooling quality for them, the way you for me.

Encourage appropriate anger and heat. Kindle the anger and heat aimed at injustice and tyranny, the corrective anger and heat aimed at cruel and self-absorbed privilege.

But also do for them what you did for me—cool the temperatures of self-righteousness and vanity.

Do for them what you did for me–teach them when to use heat and when to cool off.